Log in or become a subscriber

This content requires HR Daily Premium membership. Log in below or sign up here.

"Blurred boundaries" didn't excuse all of manager's "depraved" conduct

An employee seeking more than $650k in compensation for s-xual harassment by her manager has been awarded less than 10% of that amount, after the Federal Circuit Court found she didn't discourage his conduct nor make any effort to "reset the boundaries" between them.

It would be "disproportionate and punitive" to award her more than $35k in damages, Judge Jonathan Forbes said, due to the absence of medical evidence of harm, and because the pair's history suggested "a great deal of similar conduct was acceptable to them".

"The parties' relationship was in many respects defined by their exchange of sexually permeated conduct and content," he said, noting it was "in the very nature of the relationship that boundaries were pushed and prodded, with each party inviting the other to be the more outrageous".

"The boundaries of acceptable behaviour were so blurred and, in their private cocoon, the parties so recklessly indifferent to what others might think," that a reasonable person with knowledge of the pair would not readily anticipate offence, humiliation or intimidation, regarding most of the conduct the employee complained about, the Judge added...

Log in or become a subscriber
Subscriber login

Having trouble using your subscription? Contact us for help or check our FAQ page here for answers to commonly asked questions.

HR Daily Premium membership

Sign up now for all the benefits of HR Daily Premium membership.

Join here to stay informed

HR Daily Premium members are Australia's best-informed HR leaders and practitioners when it comes to HR news, thought leadership, legal compliance and emerging trends. Unlock premium membership to receive:

Full access to our news library Breaking news updates each day Complimentary passes to all webinars Webcasts streaming on demand Q&A sessions on hot topics And much more